Frederick Jackson Turner Frontier Thesis Held That The Frontier

Frederick Jackson Turner Frontier Thesis Held That The Frontier-36
The "frontier thesis" may long ago have lost its allure in other areas of American history, but it retains a perverse hold on students of the West.Turner, who was born in the frontier town of Portage, Wis., in 1861, and who taught history at the University of Wisconsin and Harvard University, was in effect the founder of Western historical studies.

Tags: Research Proposal International RelationsLabour Child EssayPlastic Surgery Opinion EssayCreative Writing PositionsEssays On FutureBusiness Plan Pro Premier Download30 60 90 Day Business Plan Template

He tells the story of harsh battles over land, water, language and political power -- battles that were not confined to (and did not end with) the defeat of the Western tribes.

He devotes nearly half his book to the 20th century (Billington's narrative essentially stopped in the 1890's).

But almost all agree -- some jubilantly, some ambivalently -- that the history of the American West will never look the same.

Central to almost all descriptions of the new history is an obligatory, almost ritualistic repudiation of Frederick Jackson Turner.

He is, the revisionist historians believe, the idol who must be toppled if the field is to revive and grow.

The new historians fault Turner (and his latter-day disciples) for many things, but most of all for what they consider his ethnocentrism, his triumphalism, his emphasis on individualism and his insistence that Western history as a distinct field of study ends in 1890.Were Webb alive today, however, he would discover a scholarly landscape radically different from the one he described in 1957.Western American history, transformed by a new generation of energetic revisionist scholars, is staging a vigorous and important revival.M., "none of us will ever be as influential as Turner." And so far, certainly, the revisionists have not produced a broad, forceful interpretation of the Western past in any way comparable to the "frontier thesis." Even so, the new Western history has succeeded in attracting a level of public attention (and criticism) unusual for academic scholarship.The novelist Larry Mc Murtry, for example, published a long essay in The New Republic two years ago maintaining that by their emphasis on the many failures and tragedies that undoubtedly characterized the Western past, the new Western historians overlooked the bold dreams and romantic hopes that drove so many people to "go west" to start anew.The essence of the new Western history lies in its effort to challenge the Turnerians on each of those points.Where Turner saw the 19th-century West as free land awaiting the expansion of Anglo-American settlement and American democracy, the new scholars reject the concept of a frontier altogether (and go to considerable lengths to avoid using the word).The West the new historians describe is a much less happy place -- a land in which bravery and success coexist with oppression, greed and failure; in which decaying ghost towns, bleak Indian reservations, impoverished barrios and ecologically devastated landscapes are as characteristic of Western development as great ranches, rich farms and prosperous cities.TO Turner and his disciples, the 19th-century West was a place where rugged individualism flourished and replenished American democracy.The creators of what he called "Failure Studies" had themselves failed, he said, "because they so rarely do justice to the quality of imagination that constitutes part of the truth." AND in 1991, the National Museum of American Art in Washington mounted "The West as America," a large, ambitious exhibition of 19th-century Western American art accompanied by an extensive commentary that reflected some of the assumptions of the new Western history. It was, critics such as Robert Hughes and Benjamin Forgey charged, an exercise in simple-minded "political correctness." It demonized white males and romanticized their victims.It refused to acknowledge that the Anglo-American presence in the West had contributed anything positive to the region.


Comments Frederick Jackson Turner Frontier Thesis Held That The Frontier

  • Reopening Frederick Jackson Turner's frontier - First Monday

    Three years later, Frederick Jackson Turner, considered by some to be one of the most. Turner's frontier thesis was powerfully evocative about the deep. the "trusts" reflected deeply held American suspicions of all concentrated power - and.…

  • The Turner Thesis An Annotated Bibliography for Students

    Frontier scholarship began in 1893, when Frederick Jackson Turner gave his. Turner's thesis emphasized the significance the frontier had in shaping the. and altogether unexpected ways, and how it continues to hold influence over the.…

  • A More Critical Look at Frederick Jackson Turner's America

    Frederick Jackson Turner declared in "The Significance of the Frontier in American. various waves of advancement.155 Turner's thesis became the paradigm for. of unused land held by corporations for actual settlers.164 For those who.…

  • How The Frontier Shaped The American Character.

    That after 65 years Frederick Jackson Turner's disputed “frontier theory” is still a. learned these lessons in his master's essay on “The Character and Influence. of the Frontier in American History,” read at a conference of historians held in.…

  • Civilization Over Savage Frederick Jackson Turner and the.

    I. Frederick Jackson Turner, "The Significance of the Frontier in American. History" March of America. fundamental held great promise for vitalizing the study of. American. the famous 1893 essay he said that "our early history is the study of.…

  • CONFERENCES Finding a New Place for the Frontier Thesis.

    Feb 16, 2012. CONFERENCES Finding a New Place for the Frontier Thesis. the granddaddy thesis of them all—Frederick Jackson Turner's famous and. In 1893, when the American Historical Association held its annual meeting in.…

  • People on the Land 'Closing' the Frontier Opened a New Set.

    Dec 8, 2015. In 1890, the U. S. Bureau of the Census said the American frontier was “closed”. Frederick Jackson Turner's 1893 “frontier thesis” said the end of the frontier. campaign, Hoover, an engineer, held a different view of frontier.…

  • Exploring the Western Frontier with the Records of Congress.

    Jun 26, 2017. Congress, the frontier, the Turner Thesis. the following excerpt from historian Frederick Jackson Turner's classic essay “The Significance. Hold a class discussion in which each group shares its analysis of the Turner thesis.…

The Latest from ©